Signal regularity and the mindlessness model of vigilance
William S. Helton,
Todd D. Hollander, Joel S. Warm, Gerald Matthews, William N. Dember, Matthew Wallaart, Gerald Beauchamp, Raja Parasuraman, Peter A. Hancock,
Corresponding Author
William S. Helton
Michigan Technological University, USA
Department of Psychology, Michigan Technological University, Houghton, MI 499312, USA (e-mail: [email protected]Search for more papers by this authorWilliam S. Helton,
Todd D. Hollander, Joel S. Warm, Gerald Matthews, William N. Dember, Matthew Wallaart, Gerald Beauchamp, Raja Parasuraman, Peter A. Hancock,
Corresponding Author
William S. Helton
Michigan Technological University, USA
Department of Psychology, Michigan Technological University, Houghton, MI 499312, USA (e-mail: [email protected]Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
Robertson, Manly, Andrade, Baddeley, and Yiend (1997) have proposed that detection failures in vigilance tasks result from a ‘mindless’ withdrawal of attentional effort from the monitoring assignment. To explore that view, they modified the traditional vigilance task, in which observers make button-press responses to signify the detection of rarely occurring critical signals, to one in which button-press responses acknowledge frequently occurring non-signal events and response withholding signifies signal detection. This modification is designed to promote a mindless withdrawal of attentional effort from the task through routinization. The present study challenges the validity of the mindlessness model by showing that with both types of task, observers utilize subtle patterns in the temporal structure of critical signal appearances to develop expectations about the time course of those appearances that affect performance efficiency. Such expectations enhance performance on the traditional vigilance task, but degrade performance on the modified task.
References
- Baars, B. J. The conscious access hypothesis: Origins and recent evidence. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 6 47–52 2002.
- Broadbent, D. E. Decision and stress New York, Academic Press. 1971.
- Broadbent, D. E. Cooper, P. Fitzgerald, P. Parks, K. The cognitive failures questionnaire (CFQ) and its correlates. British Journal of Clinical Psychology 21 1–16 1982.
- Chun, M. M. Jiang, Y. Contextual cueing: Implicit learning and memory of visual context guides spatial attention. Cognitive Psychology 36 28–71 1998.
- Coren, S. Ward, L. M. Enns, J. T. Sensation and perception 6th ed. Hoboken, NJ, Wiley. 2004.
- Davies, D. R. Parasuraman, R. The psychology of vigilance London, Academic Press. 1982.
- Davies, D. R. Tune, G. S. Human vigilance performance New York, American Elsevier. 1969.
- Dickman, S. J. Dimensions of arousal: Wakefulness and vigor. Human Factors 44 429–442 2002.
- Doyon, J. Penhune, V. Ungerleider, L. G. Distinct contribution of the cortico-striatal and cortico-cerebellar systems in motor skill learning. Neuropsychologia 41 252–262 2003.
- Gazzaniga, M. S. Ivry, R. B. Mangun, G. R. Cognitive neuroscience: The biology of the mind 2nd ed. New York, Norton. 2002.
- Grier, R. A. Warm, J. S. Dember, W. N. Matthews, G. Galinsky, T. L. Szalma, J. L. Parasuraman, R. The vigilance decrement reflects limitations in effortful attention not mindlessness. Human Factors 45 349–359 2003.
- Grubb, P. L. Miller, L. C. Nelson, W. T. Warm, J. S. Dember, W. N. Davies, D. R. Cognitive failure and perceived workload in vigilance performance M. Mouloua. R. Parasuraman Human performance in automated systems: Current research and trends. 115–121, Hillsdale, NJ, Erlbaum. 1994.
- Haarington, D. L. Haaland, K. Y. Hemispheric specialization for motor sequencing: Abnormalities in levels of programming. Neuropsychologia 29 147–163 1991.
-
Hancock, P. A. Hart, S. G.
Defeating terrorism: What can human factors/ergonomics offer?.
Ergonomics and Design
10 6–16 2002.
10.1177/106480460201000103 Google Scholar
- Hancock, P. A. Warm, J. S. A dynamic model of stress and sustained attention. Human Factors 31 519–537 1989.
- Hart, S. G. Staveland, L. E. Development of NASA-TLX (Task Load Index): Results of empirical and theoretical research P. A. Hancock. N. Meshkati Human mental workload. 139–183, Amsterdam, North-Holland. 1988.
- Hellige, J. B. Hemispheric asymmetry: What's right and what's left Cambridge, MA, Harvard University Press. 1993.
- Helton, W. S. Dember, W. N. Warm, J. S. Matthews, G. Optimism, pessimism, and false failure feedback: Effects on vigilance performance. Current Psychology 18 311–325 1999.
-
Helton, W. S. Warm, J. S. Matthews, G. Corcoran, K. Dember, W. N.
Effects of signal salience and jet aircraft engine noise on performance and stress in an abbreviated vigilance task.
Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society
46 1546–1551 2002.
10.1177/154193120204601704 Google Scholar
- Hitchcock, E. M. Dember, W. N. Warm, J. S. Maroney, B. W. See, J. Effects of cueing and knowledge of results on workload and boredom in sustained attention. Human Factors 41 365–372 1999.
-
Hitchcock, E. M. Warm, J. S. Matthews, G. Dember, W. N. Shear, P. K. Tripp, L. D. Mayleben, D. W. Parasuraman, R.
Automation cueing modulates cerebral blood flow and vigilance in a simulated air traffic control task.
Theoretical Issues in Ergonomic Science
4 89–112 2003.
10.1080/14639220210159726 Google Scholar
- Hollander, T. D. Warm, J. S. Matthews, G. Dember, W. N. Tripp, L. D. & Parasuraman, R. (November, 2003). Cerebral hemovelocity and the signal regularity effect in vigilance. Paper presented at the meeting of the Psychonomic Society, Vancouver, British Columbia.
- Kemeny, M. E. The psychobiology of stress. Current Directions in Psychological Science 12 124–129 2003.
- Kirk, R. E. Experimental design: Procedures for the behavioral sciences 3rd ed. Pacific Grove, CA, Brooks/Cole. 1995.
-
A. F. Kramer. M. G. H. Coles. G. D. Logan
Converging operations in the study of visual selective attention Washington, DC, American Psychological Association. 1996.
10.1037/10187-000 Google Scholar
-
LaBerge, D.
Attentional processing: The brain's art of mindfulness Cambridge, Harvard University Press. 1995.
10.4159/harvard.9780674183940 Google Scholar
- Langer, E. J. Mindfulness Reading, MA, Addison-Wesley. 1989.
- Loeb, M. Binford, J. R. Vigilance for auditory intensity changes as a function of preliminary feedback and confidence level. Human Factors 7 445–458 1964.
- Logan, G. D. Cowan, W. B. On the ability to inhibit thought and action: A theory of an act of control. Psychological Review 91 295–327 1984.
- Manly, T. Robertson, I. H. Galloway, M. Hawkins, K. The absent mind: Further investigations of sustained attention to response. Neuropsychologia 37 661–670 1999.
- Matthews, G. Levels of transaction: A cognitive science framework for operator stress P. A. Hancock. P. A. Desmond Stress, workload, and fatigue. 5–33, Mahwah, NJ, Erlbaum. 2001.
- Matthews, G. Campbell, S. E. Falconer, S. Joyner, L. A. Huggins, J. Gilliland, K. Grier, R. Warm, J. S. Fundamental dimensions of subjective state performance settings: Task engagement, distress, and worry. Emotion 2 315–340 2002.
- Matthews, G. Davies, D. R. Westerman, S. J. Stammers, R. B. Human performance: Cognition, stress and individual differences East Sussex, UK, Psychology Press. 2000.
- Matthews, G. Joyner, L. Campbell, S. E. Gilliland, K. Huggins, J. Falconer, S. Validation of a comprehensive stress state questionnaire: Towards a state big three? I. Merville. I. J. Deary. F. DeFruyt. F. Ostendorf Personality psychology in Europe, 7: 335–350, Tilburg, Tilburg University Press. 1999.
- Matthews, G. Wells, A. Attentional processes, coping strategies and clinical intervention M. Zeidner. N. S. Endler Handbook of coping: Theory, research, applications. 573–601, New York, Wiley. 1996.
- Maxwell, S. E. Delaney, H. D. Designing experiments and analyzing data: A model comparison perspective 2nd ed. Mahwah, NJ, Erlbaum. 2004.
-
Norman, D. A. Shallice, T.
Attention to action: Willed and automatic control of behavior R. J. Davidson. G. E. Schwartz. D. Shapiro
Consciousness and self-regulation: Advances in research, 4: 1–17, New York, Plenum. 1986.
10.1007/978-1-4757-0629-1_1 Google Scholar
- Nygren, T. E. Psychometric properties of subjective workload measurement techniques: Implications for their use in the assessment of perceived mental workload. Human Factors 33 17–33 1991.
- Reason, J. Lapses in attention in everyday life R. Parasuraman. D. R. Davies Varieties of attention. 515–549, Orlando, FL, Academic Press. 1984.
- Robertson, I. H. Manly, T. Andrade, J. Baddeley, B. T. Yiend, J. Oops!: Performance correlates of everyday attentional failures in traumatic brain injured and normal subjects. Neuropsychologia 35 747–758 1997.
- Sanders, A. F. Elements of human performance: Reaction processes and attention in human skill Mahwah, NJ, Erlbaum. 1998.
- Scerbo, M. W. Warm, J. S. Fisk, A. D. Event asynchrony and signal regularity in sustained attention. Current Psychological Research and Reviews 5 335–343 1986.
-
Shallice, T.
From neuropsychology to mental structure Cambridge, UK, Cambridge University Press. 1988.
10.1017/CBO9780511526817 Google Scholar
- Smallwood, J. Davies, J. B. Heim, D. Finnigan, F. Sudberry, M. O'Conner, R. Obonsawin, M. Subjective experience and the attentional lapse: Task engagement and disengagement during sustained attention. Consciousness and Cognition 13 657–690 2004.
- Stuss, D. T. Shallice, T. Alexander, M. P. Picton, T. W. A multidisciplinary approach to anterior attentional functions. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 769 191–209 1995.
- Szalma, J. L. Warm, J. S. Matthews, G. Dember, W. N. Wiler, E. M. Meier, A. Eggemeier. Effects of sensory modality and task duration on performance, workload, and stress in sustained attention. Human Factors 46 219–233 2004.
- Temple, J. G. Warm, J. S. Dember, W. N. Jones, K. S. LaGrange, C. M. Matthews, G. The effects of signal salience and caffeine on performance, workload, and stress in an abbreviated vigilance task. Human Factors 42 183–194 2000.
- Tucker, D. M. Williamson, P. A. Asymmetric neural control systems in human self-regulation. Psychological Review 91 185–215 1984.
- Warm, J. S. An introduction to vigilance J. S. Warm Sustained attention in human performance. 1–14, Chichester, UK, Wiley. 1984.
- Warm, J. S. Vigilance and target detection B. M. Huey. C. D. Wickens Workload transition: Implications for individual and team performance. 139–170, Washington, DC, National Academy Press. 1993.
-
Warm, J. S. Dember, W. N.
Tests of a vigilance taxonomy R. R. Hoffman. M. F. Sherrick. J. S. Warm
Viewing psychology as a whole: The integrative science of William N. Dember. 87–112, Washington, DC, American Psychological Association. 1998.
10.1037/10290-004 Google Scholar
- Warm, J. S. Dember, W. N. Hancock, P. A. Vigilance and workload in automated systems R. Parasuraman. M. Mouloua Automation and human performance: Theory and applications. 183–200, Mahwah, NJ, Prentice-Hall. 1996.
- Warm, J. S. Dember, W. N. Murphy, A. Z. Dittmar, M. L. Sensing and decision-making components of the signal-regularity effect in vigilance performance. Bulletin of the Psychonomic Society 30 297–300 1992.
- Warm, J. S. Jerison, H. J. The psychophysics of vigilance J. S. Warm Sustained attention in human performance. 15–59, Chichester, UK, Wiley. 1984.
- Warm, J. S. Kanfer, F. H. Kuwada, S. Clark, J. L. Motivation and vigilance: Effect of self-evaluation and experimenter controlled feedback. Journal of Experimental Psychology 92 123–127 1972.
- Wickens, C. D. Hollands, J. G. Engineering psychology and human performance 3rd ed. Upper Saddle River, NJ, Prentice Hall. 2000.
