Smoking and peer groups: Results from a longitudinal qualitative study of young people in Northern Ireland
Corresponding Author
Barbara J. Stewart-Knox
Northern Ireland Centre for Food and Health (NICHE), University of Ulster, UK
Correspondence should be addressed to Barbara J. Stewart-Knox, Northern Ireland Centre for Food and Health (NICHE), University of Ulster, Coleraine BT52 1SA. UK (e-mail: [email protected]).Search for more papers by this authorJulie Sittlington
Northern Ireland Centre for Food and Health (NICHE), University of Ulster, UK
Search for more papers by this authorSheila Harrisson
Northern Ireland Centre for Food and Health (NICHE), University of Ulster, UK
Search for more papers by this authorCorresponding Author
Barbara J. Stewart-Knox
Northern Ireland Centre for Food and Health (NICHE), University of Ulster, UK
Correspondence should be addressed to Barbara J. Stewart-Knox, Northern Ireland Centre for Food and Health (NICHE), University of Ulster, Coleraine BT52 1SA. UK (e-mail: [email protected]).Search for more papers by this authorJulie Sittlington
Northern Ireland Centre for Food and Health (NICHE), University of Ulster, UK
Search for more papers by this authorSheila Harrisson
Northern Ireland Centre for Food and Health (NICHE), University of Ulster, UK
Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
Previous research has indicated that young people are under considerable social pressure to take up smoking. This study has therefore sought to explore and better understand the mechanisms through which peer-related social factors operate to encourage young people to smoke. Individual qualitative interviews were held with adolescent children aged 11–12 years (N=102) within youth clubs based in economically deprived areas of Northern Ireland, and then followed up on two occasions during the subsequent 3 years (N=51/39). The data implied that, although peers influence smoking uptake, this seldom happens through direct persuasion, but rather as the result of the young person striving to conform to the normative behaviour of the peer group with which they identify. The findings are consistent with social identity theory and self-categorization theory in that for both smoking and non-smoking 14-year-olds smoking activity appears to provide a means through which to define social groups, to accentuate similarity within groups and differences between groups. In-group favouritism was expressed in the sharing of cigarettes within the in-group and in the negative stereotyping of out-group members. There was some evidence that group affiliation may be negotiated differently for boys and girls. These findings imply that successful intervention needs to reconsider the normative processes that encourage young people to smoke.
References
- Allbutt, H. Amos, A. Cunningham-Burley, S. The social image of smoking among young people in Scotland Health Education Research 10 443–454 1995.
- Aloise-Young, P. Graham, J. W. Hansen, W. P. Peer influence on smoking initiation during early adolescence: A comparison of group members and group outsiders Journal of Applied Psychology 79 281–287 1994.
- Bat-Chava, Y. Diversity of deaf identities American Annals of the Deaf 145 420–429 2000.
- Bennett, M. Children and social identity Psychologist 17 512–514 2004.
- Burnard, P. A method of analysing interview transcripts in qualitative research Nurse Education Today 11 461–466 1991.
- Charlton, A. Minagawa, K. E. While, D. Saying no to cigarettes: A reappraisal of adolescent refusal skills Journal of Adolescence 22 695–707 1999.
- Clarke, J. Borland, R. McGartland, M. The effects of smoking outside workplaces on non-regular smokers Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine 39 734–739 1997.
- Clayton, S. Gender differences in psychosocial determinants of adolescent smoking Journal of School Health 61 115–120 1991.
- Conrad, K. M. Flay, B. R. Hill, D. Why children start smoking cigarettes: Predictors of onset British Journal of Addiction 87 1711–1724 1992.
- Cotterell, J. Social networks and social influences in adolescence cha6 London Routledge 1996.
- Denscomb, M. Peer group pressure, young people and smoking: New developments and policy implications Drugs: Education, Preventions and Policy 8 7–31 2001b.
- Denscomb, M. Uncertain identities and health risk taking behaviour: The case of young people and smoking in late modernity British Journal of Sociology 52 157–177 2001a.
- Department of Health Smoking kills. A White Paper on tobacco London The Stationery Office 1998.
- Deschamps, J. C. Differenciations entre soi et autri et entre groupes J. P. Codol J. P. Leyens Cognitive analysis of social behaviour The Hague Nijhoff 1982.
- Fedele, M. Borland, R. Characteristics of exiled smoking from workplaces Psychology and Health 13 545–554 1998.
- Fekadu, Z. Kraft, P. Expanding the theory of planned behaviour: The role of social norms and group identification Journal of Health Psychology 7 33–43 2002.
- Flay, B. d'Avernas, J. Best, J. A. Kersell, M. Ryan, K. Cigarette smoking: Why young people do it and ways of preventing it P. McGrath P. Firestone Pediatric and adolescent behavioural medicine 97–127 New York Springer 1983.
- Friedman, L. Lichenstein, E. Biglan, A. Smoking onset among teens: An empirical analysis of initial situations Addictive Behaviors 10 1–13 1985.
- Harris, P. Middleton, W. Joiner, R. The typical student as an in-group member: Eliminating optimistic bias by reducing social distance European Journal of Social Psychology 30 235–253 2000.
- Haslam, S. A. McGarty, C. Oakes, J. Turner, J. Social comparative context and illusionary correlation Australian Journal of Psychology 45 97–101 1993.
- Haslam, S. A. Oakes, P. J. Turner, J. C. Onorato, R. S. Contextual changes in the prototypicality of extreme and moderate outgroup members European Journal of Social Psychology 25 509–530 1995.
- Haslam, S. A. Turner, J. C. Oakes, P. J. Reynolds, K. J. Eggins, R. A. Nolan, M. Tweedie, J. When do stereotypes become really consensual? Investigating the group-based dynamics of the consensualization process European Journal of Social Psychology 28 755–776 1998.
- Health Promotion Agency for Northern Ireland The health behaviour of school children in Northern Ireland. A report on the 1997–98 survey Belfast Author 2000.
- Heaven, P. C. L. Caputi, P. Trivellion-Scott, D. Swinton, T. Personality and group influences on self-reported delinquent behaviour Personality and Individual Differences 28 1143–1158 2000.
- Hogg, M. A. Abrahams, D. Social identifications: A social psychology of intergroup relations and group processes London Routledge and Kegan Paul 1988.
- Hogg, M. A. Turner, J. C. Davidson, B. Polarized norms and social frames of reference: A test of the self-categorization theory of group polarization Basic and Applied Social Psychology 11 77–100 1990.
- Jackson, J. W. Smith, E. R. Conceptualizing social identity: A framework and evidence for the impact of different dimensions Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 25 120–135 1999.
- Janesick, V. J. The dance of qualitative research design N. K. Denzin Y. S. Lincoln Strategies of qualitative enquiry (pp. 35–55) London Sage 1998.
- Kirchler, E. Palmonari, A. Pombeni, L. M. Social categorisation processes as dependent on status differences between groups: A step into adolescents' peer-groups European Journal of Social Psychology 24 541–563 1994.
- Lloyd, B. Lucas, K. Smoking in adolescence: Images and identities London Routledge 1998.
- Lord, C. G. Social psychology cha 15 Fort Worth, TX: Harcourt Brace 1997.
- Lucas, K. Lloyd, B. Starting smoking: Girls' explanations of the influence of peers Journal of Adolescence 22 647–655 1999.
- Marsh, A. McKay, S. Poor smokers London Political Studies Institute 1994.
- McGarty, C. Haslam, S. A. Hutchinson, K. J. Turner, J. C. The effects of salient group memberships on persuasion Small Groups Research 25 267–293 1994.
- Merton, R. Kendall, P. Reduced fat foods: The shopper's viewpoint International Journal of Consumer Studies 26 44–57 1956.
- Michell, L. Loud, sad or bad: Young people's perceptions of peer groups and smoking Health Education Research 12 1–14 1997.
- Michell, L. Amos, A. Girls, pecking order and smoking Social Science and Medicine 44 1861–1869 1997.
- Michell, L. West, P. Peer pressure to smoke: The meaning depends on the method Health Education Research 11 39–49 1996.
- Newman, B. M. Newman, P. R. Group identity and alienation: Giving the we its due Journal of Youth and Adolescence 30 515–538 2001.
- Palmonari, A. Pombeni, M. L. Kirchler, E. Adolescents and their peer groups: A study on the significance of peers, social categorisation processes and coping with developmental tasks Social Behaviour 5 33–48 1990.
- Pavis, S. Cunningham-Burley, S. Amos, A. Health related behavioural change in context: Young people in transition Social Science and Medicine 47 1407–1418 1998.
- Pearson, M. Michell, L. Smoke rings: Social network analysis of friendship groups, smoking and drug taking Drugs: Education, Prevention and Policy 7 21–37 2000.
- Pedersen, W. Bittersøtt. Ungdom, Sosialisering. Rusmidler (Bittersweet. Young people. Socialisation. Drugs) Oslo Universitetsforlaget 1998.
- Reynolds, K. J. Turner, J. C. Haslam, S. A. When are we better than them and they worse than us? A closer look at social discrimination in positive and negative domains Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 78 64–80 2000.
- Reynolds, K. J. Turner, J. C. Haslam, S. A. Ryan, N. K. The role of personality and group factors when explaining prejudice Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 37 427–434 2001.
- Rugkåsa, J. Knox, B. Sittlington, J. Kennedy, O. Treacy, M. P. Abaunza, P. S. Anxious adults vs cool children: Children's views on smoking and addiction Social Science and Medicine 53 593–602 2001a.
- Rugkåsa, J. Stewart-Knox, B. Sittlington, J. Abaunza, P. S. Treacy, M. P. Hard boys – attractive girls: Expressions of gender in young people's conversations on smoking Health Promotion International 18 307–314 2004.
- Schmitt, M. T. Branscombe, N. R. Kappen, D. M. Attitudes toward group-based inequality: Social dominance or social identity? British Journal of Social Psychology 42 161–186 2003.
- Schofield, P. E. Pattison, P. E. Hill, D. J. Borland, R. The influence of group identification on the adoption of peer group smoking norms Psychology and Health 16 1–16 2001.
- Strauss, A. Corbin, J. Grounded theory methodology. An overview N. K. Denzin Y. S. Lincoln Strategies of qualitative enquiry 158–183 London Sage 1998.
- Tajfel, H. Human groups and social categories, studies in social psychology Cambridge Cambridge University Press 1981.
- Tajfel, H. Turner, J. C. The social identity theory of intergroup behaviour S. Worchel W. G. Austin Psychology of intergroup relations 7–24 Chicago Nelson-Hall 1986.
- Tarrant, M. North, A. C. Edridge, M. D. Kirk, L. E. Smith, E. A. Turner, R. E. Social Identity in adolescence Journal of Adolescence 24 597–609 2001.
- Tarrant, M. North, A. C. Hargreaves, D. J. Social categorisation, self esteem, and the estimated musical preferences of male adolescents Journal of Social Psychology 141 565–581 2001.
- Terry, D. J. Hogg, M. A. Group norms and the attitude–behavior relationship: A role for group identification Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 22 776–793 1996.
- Turner, J. C. Oakes, P. J. Haslam, S. A. McGarty, C. Self and collective: Cognition and social context Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 20 454–463 1994.
- Urberg, K. A. Shyu, S. Liang, J. Peer influence in adolescent cigarette smoking Addictive Behaviours 15 247–255 1990.
- Wiltshire, S. Bancroft, A. Amos, A. Parry, O. They're doing people a service: Qualitative study of smoking, smuggling, and social deprivation British Medical Journal 323 203–207 2001.
- World Health Organization Health and health behaviour among young people Copenhagen Author 2000.