Post-traumatic growth and life threatening physical illness: A systematic review of the qualitative literature
Corresponding Author
Kate Hefferon
Department of Psychology, University of Strathclyde, Scotland, UK
Correspondence should be addressed to Kate Hefferon, Department of Psychology, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow G11QE, Scotland, UK (e-mail: [email protected]).Search for more papers by this authorMadeleine Grealy
Department of Psychology, University of Strathclyde, Scotland, UK
Search for more papers by this authorNanette Mutrie
Department of Sport, Culture and Arts, University of Strathclyde, Scotland, UK
Search for more papers by this authorCorresponding Author
Kate Hefferon
Department of Psychology, University of Strathclyde, Scotland, UK
Correspondence should be addressed to Kate Hefferon, Department of Psychology, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow G11QE, Scotland, UK (e-mail: [email protected]).Search for more papers by this authorMadeleine Grealy
Department of Psychology, University of Strathclyde, Scotland, UK
Search for more papers by this authorNanette Mutrie
Department of Sport, Culture and Arts, University of Strathclyde, Scotland, UK
Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
Post-traumatic growth (PTG) is the phenomenon of positive change through the experience of trauma and adversity (O'Leary & Ickovics, 1995). Research suggests that the type of trauma sustained could have differing processes and outcomes from each other (Demark-wahnefried et al., 2000; Sabiston, McDonough, and Crocker, 2007). The aim of this study was to synthesize qualitative data on PTG and illness related trauma. Fifty-seven published journal articles dating from before November 1st, 2007 in PsychINFO, MEDLINE, EMBASE, Web of Knowledge and from the authors own knowledge of the area were reviewed. Key words included PTG; benefit finding; thriving and positive changes. Key themes included: ‘reappraisal of life and priorities’; ‘trauma equals development of self’; ‘existential re-evaluation’; and ‘a new awareness of the body’. Findings suggest that there are unique elements to illness related PTG and a need for additional research into the processes and outcomes of physical illness related trauma.
References
- Abraido-Lanza, A. F. Guier, C. Colon, R. Psychological thriving among Latinas with chronic illness Journal of Social Issues 54 405–424 1998.
- Affleck, G. Tennen, H. Croog, S. Levine, S. Causal attribution, perceived benefits, and morbidity after a heart attack: An 8-year study Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 55 29–35 1987.
- Arman, M. Backman, M. A longitudinal study on women's experiences of life with breast cancer in anthroposophical (complementary) and conventional care European Journal of Cancer Care 16 444–450 2007.
- Arman, M. Rehnsfeldt, A. Living with breast cancer – a challenge to expansive and creative forces European Journal of Cancer Care 11 290–296 2002.
- Arman, M. Rehnsfeldt, A. Carlsson, M. Hamrin, E. Indications of change in life perspective among women with breast cancer admitted to complementary care European Journal of Cancer Care 10 192–200 2001.
- Barakat, L. P. Alderfer, M. A. Kazak, A. E. Posttraumatic growth in adolescent survivors of cancer and their mothers and fathers Journal of Paediatric Psychology 31 4 413–419 2006.
- Barroso, J. Gollup, C. Sandelowski, M. Meynell, J. Pearce, P. Collins, L. The challenge of searching for and retrieving qualitative studies Western Journal of Nursing Research 25 153–178 2003.
- Bates, M. The design of browsing and berrypicking techniques for the online search interface Online Review 13 149–159 1989.
- Belec, R. Quality of life: Perceptions of long-term survivors of bone marrow transplantation Oncology Nursing Forum 19 31–37 1992.
- Britten, N. Campbell, R. Pope, C. Donovan, J. Morgan, M. Pill, R. Using meta ethnography to synthesise qualitative research: A worked example Journal of Health Services Research and Policy 7 209–215 2002.
- Carpenter, J. S. Self-transformation as a factor in the self-esteem and well-being of breast cancer survivors Journal of Advanced Nursing 29 1402–1411 1999.
- Carver, S. Resilience and thriving: Issues, models, and linkages Journal of Social Issues 54 245–266 1998.
- Cella, D. Tross, S. Psychological adjustment to survival from Hodgkin's disease Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 54 616–622 1986.
- Collins, R. L. Taylor, S. E. Skokan, L. A. A better world or a shattered vision? Changes in perspectives following victimization Social Cognition 8 263–285 1990.
- Coward, D. Kahn, D. Transcending breast cancer: Making meaning from diagnosis and treatment Journal of Holistic Nursing 23 264–283 2005.
- Coward, D. Lewis, F. The lived experience of transcendence in gay men with AIDS Oncology Nursing Forum 20 1363–1368 1993.
- Curtin, R. B. Mapes, D. Petillo, M. Oberley, E. Long-term dialysis survivors: A transformational experience Qualitative Health 12 5 609–624 1997.
- Dahan, J. F. Auerbach, C. F. Qualitative study of the trauma and posttraumatic growth of multiple myeloma patients treated with peripheral blood stem cell transplant Palliative and Supportive Care 4 4 365–387 2006.
- Daiter, S. Larson, R. Weddington, W. Ultman, J. Psychosocial symptomatology, personal growth, and development among young adult patients following the diagnosis of leukemia lymphoma Journal of Clinical Oncology 6 613–617 1988.
- Daly, J. Willis, K. Small, R. Green, J. Welch, N. Kealy, M. Hughes, E. A hierarchy of evidence for assessing qualitative health research Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 60 43–49 2006.
- Danoff-Burg, S. Revenson, T. Benefit-finding among patients with rheumatoid arthritis: Positive effects on interpersonal relationships Journal of Behavioral Medicine 28 91–103 2005.
-
Demark-Wahnefried, W. Peterson, B. McBride, C. Lipkus, I. Clipp, E. C.
Current health behaviours and readiness to pursue lifestyle change among men and women diagnosed with early-stage prostate and breast cancer
Cancer
88 674–684 2000.
10.1002/(SICI)1097-0142(20000201)88:3<674::AID-CNCR26>3.0.CO;2-R CASPubMedWeb of Science®Google Scholar
- Dildy, S. P. Suffering in people with rheumatoid arthritis Applied Nursing Research 9 177–183 1996.
-
Dixon-Woods, M. Booth, A. Sutton
Synthesising qualitative research: A review of published reports
Qualitative Research
7 375–422 2007.
10.1177/1468794107078517 Google Scholar
- Dixon-Woods, M. Argarwal, S. Jones, D. Young, B. Sutton, A. Synthesising qualitative and quantitative evidence: A review of possible methods Journal of Health Services Research and Policy 10 45–53 2005.
-
Dixon-Woods, M. Bonas, S. Booth, A. Jones, D. Miller, T. Sutton, A. et al.
How can systematic reviews incorporate qualitative research? A critical perspective
Qualitative Research
6 27–44 2006.
10.1177/1468794106058867 Google Scholar
- Dunn, J. Lynch, B. Rinaldis, M. Pakenham, L. Owen, N. Leggett, B. et al. Dimensions of quality of life and psychosocial variables most salient to colorectal cancer patients Psycho-Oncology 15 20–30 2006.
- Edvardsson, T. Pahlson, A. Ahlstrom, G. Experiences of onset diagnosis of low-grade glioma from the patient's perspective Cancer Nursing 29 415–422 2006.
- Eide, P. Hawaiian women and the experience of breast cancer Women and Health 44 4 41–59 2006.
- Emslie, C. Women, men and coronary heart disease: A review of the qualitative literature Journal of Advanced Nursing 51 382–395 2005.
- Emslie C. & Hunt K. (in press). Men, masculinities and heart disease: A systematic review of the qualitative literature. Current Sociology.
- Fatone, A. M. Moadel, A. B. Foley, F. W. Fleming, M. Jandorf, L. Urban voices: The quality-of-life experience among women of color with breast cancer Palliative and Supportive Care 5 115–125 2007.
- Frankl, V. Man's search for meaning New York Pocket books 1984.
- Fredette, S. L. Breast cancer survivors-concerns and coping Cancer Nursing 18 1 35–46 1995.
- Fromm, K. Andrykowski, M. Hunt, J. Positive and negative psychosocial sequelae of bone marrow transplantation: Implication for quality of life assessment Journal of Behavioral Medicine 19 221–240 1996.
- Gillen, G. Positive consequences of surviving a stroke American Journal of Occupational Therapy 59 346–350 2005.
- Gotay, C. Holup, J. Muraoka, M. Y. The challenges of prostate cancer: A major men's health issue International Journal of Men's Health 1 59–72 2002.
- Hassin, J. Living a responsible life- the impact of AIDS on the social identity of intravenous drug users Social science and Medicine 39 3 391–400 1994.
-
Heiland, M. F. Goggin, K. Brandt-Kessler, K. Brammer, A. Nollen, N. Murray, T. et al.
Reconstruction of meaning and identity in the wake of new treatments for HIV disease
Journal of Psychology and Human Sexuality
14 55–79 2002.
10.1300/J056v14n01_05 Google Scholar
- Johansson, K. Holmstrom, H. Nilsson, I. Ingvar, C. Albertsson, M. Ekdahl, C. Breast cancer patients' experiences of lymphoedema Scandinavian Journal of Caring Sciences 17 35–42 2003.
-
Kennedy, B. J. Tellegen, A. Kennedy, S. Havernick, N.
Psychological responses of patients cured of advanced cancer
Cancer
38 2184–2191 1976.
10.1002/1097-0142(197611)38:5<2184::AID-CNCR2820380549>3.0.CO;2-9 CASPubMedWeb of Science®Google Scholar
- Kyngas, H. Mikkonen, R. Nousiainen, E. Rytilahti, M. Seppanen, P. Vaattovaara, R. et al. Coping with the onset of cancer: Coping strategies and resources of young people with cancer European Journal of Cancer Care 10 6–11 2001.
- Laerum, E. Johnsen, N. Smith, P. Larsen, S. Can myocardial infarction induce positive changes in family relationships? Family Practice 4 4 302–305 1987.
- Laerum, E. Johnsen, N. Smith, P. Larsen, S. Myocardial infarction may induce positive changes in life-style and in the quality of life Scandinavian Journal of Primary Health Care 6 2 67–71 1988.
- Lam, W. Fielding, R. The evolving experience of illness for Chinese women with breast cancer: A qualitative study Psycho-oncology 12 127–140 2003.
- Lev-Wiesel, R. Amir, M. Growing out of ashes L. G. Calhoun R. Tedeschi Handbook of post-traumatic growth: Research and practice 248–263 Mahwah, NJ Erlbaum 2006.
- Linley, A. Joseph, S. Positive changes following trauma and adversity: A review Journal of Traumatic Stress 17 11–21 2004.
- Luoma, M. L. Hakamies-Blomqvist, L. The meaning of quality of life in patients being treated for advanced breast cancer: A qualitative study Psycho-oncology 13 729–739 2004.
- Maercker, A. Zoellner, T. The Janus face of self-perceived growth: Toward a two-component model of posttraumatic growth Psychological Inquiry 15 41–48 2004.
- Manuel, J. C. Burwell, S. R. Crawford, S. L. Lawrence, R. Farmer, D. Hege, A.,. et al. Younger women's perceptions of coping with breast cancer Cancer Nursing 30 85–94 2007.
- Milne, H. M. Guilfoyle, A. Gordon, S. Wallman, K. Courneya, K. Personal accounts of exercise and quality of life from the perspective of breast cancer survivors Quality of Life Research 16 9 1473–1481 2007.
-
Noblit, G. W. Hare, R. D.
Meta-ethnography: Synthesizing qualitative studies London Sage Publications 1988.
10.4135/9781412985000 Google Scholar
- Nolen-Hoeksema, S. Davis, C. Positive response to loss C. R. Snyder S. Lopez Handbook of positive psychology 598–607 New York Oxford University Press 2004.
- O'Connor, A. Wicker, C. Germino, B. Understanding the cancer patients search for meaning Cancer Nursing 13 167–175 1990.
- O'Leary, V. Ickovics, J. Resilience and thriving in response to challenge: An opportunity for a paradigm shift in women's health Women's Health: Research on Gender, Behaviour and Policy 1 121–142 1995.
- Pakenham, K. I. The nature of benefit finding in multiple sclerosis (MS) Psychology Health and Medicine 12 190–196 2007.
- Park, C. Lechner, S. Measurement issues in assessing growth following stressful life experiences L. G. Calhoun R. Tedeschi Handbook of post-traumatic growth: Research and practice 47–67 Mahwah, NJ Erlbaum 2006.
- Parry, C. Embracing uncertainty: An exploration of the experiences of childhood cancer survivors Qualitative Health research 13 227–246 2003.
- Parry, C. Chesler, M. A. Thematic evidence of psychosocial thriving in childhood cancer survivors Qualitative Health Research 15 1055–1073 2005.
- Paterson, B. Thorne, S. Crawford, J. Tarko, M. Living with diabetes as a transformational experience Qualitative Health Research 9 786–802 1999.
- Paton, D. Posttraumatic growth in disaster and emergency work L. G. Calhoun R. Tedeschi Handbook of post-traumatic growth: Research and practice 225–245 Mahwah, NJ Erlbaum 2006.
- Petrie, K. J. Buick, D. L. Weinman, J. Booth, R. J. Positive effects of illness reported by myocardial infarction and breast cancer patients Journal of Psychosomatic Research 47 6 537–543 1999.
- Power, R. Tate, H. L. McGill, S. Taylor, C. A qualitative study of the psychosocial implications of lipodystrophy syndrome on HIV positive individuals Sexually transmitted Infections 79 137–141 2003.
- Rosner, R. Powell, S. Posttraumatic growth after war L. G. Calhoun R. Tedeschi Handbook of post-traumatic growth: Research and practice 197–213 Mahwah, NJ Erlbaum 2006.
- Rothschild, B. The body remembers California W.W Norton and Company 2000.
-
Russell, C. S. White, M. B. White, C. P.
Why me? Why now? Why multiple sclerosis? Making meaning and perceived quality of life in a Midwestern sample of patients with multiple sclerosis
Families, Systems, and Health
24 65–81 2006.
10.1037/1091-7527.24.1.65 Google Scholar
- Sabiston, C. M. McDonough, M. H. Crocker, P. Psychosocial experiences of breast cancer survivors involved in a dragon boat program: Exploring links to positive psychological growth Journal of Sport and Exercise Science 29 419–438 2007.
- Salick, E. Auerbach, C. From devastation to integration: Adjusting to and growing from medical trauma Qualitative Health Research 16 8 1021–1037 2006.
- Schwartzberg, S. Struggling for meaning: How HIV-positive gay men make sense of AIDS Professional Psychology: Research and Practice 24 483–490 1993.
- Schwartzberg, S. Vitality and growth in HIV-infected gay men Social Science and Medicine 38 593–602 1994.
- Siegel, K. Schrimshaw, E. Perceiving benefits in adversity: Stress related growth in women living with HIV Social Science and Medicine 51 1543–1554 2000.
- Sodregen, S. C. Hyland, M. E. What are the positive consequences of illness? Psychology and Health 15 1 85–97 2000.
- Taleghani, F. Yekta, Z. P. Nasrabadi, A. N. Coping with breast cancer in newly diagnosed Iranian women Journal of Advanced Nursing 54 265–272 2006.
- Tandon, S. Mehrotra, S. Encounters with cancer: Illustrating the process of psychological adaptation Psychological Studies 52 54–61 2007.
- Tartaro, J. Roberts, J. Nosarti, C. Crayford, T. Luecken, L. David, A. Who benefits? Distress, adjustment and benefit-finding among breast cancer survivors Journal of Psychosocial Oncology 23 45–64 2005.
- Taylor, S. Lichtman, R. Wood, J. Attributions, beliefs about control and adjustment to breast cancer Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 46 489–502 1984.
-
Tedeschi, R. Calhoun, L.
Trauma and transformation: Growing in the aftermath of suffering Thousand Oaks, CA Sage 1995.
10.4135/9781483326931 Google Scholar
- Tedeschi, R. G. Calhoun, L. G. Foundations of posttraumatic growth R. G. Tedeschi L. Calhoun Handbook of posttraumatic growth 3–23 New Jersey Erlbaum 2006.
- Thomas, J. & Harden, A. (2007). Methods for the thematic synthesis of qualitative research in systematic reviews. NCRM Working Paper Series Number (10/07).
- Thornton, A. A. Perceiving benefits in the cancer experience Journal of Clinical Psychology in Medical Settings 9 2 153–165 2002.
-
Tompkins, T. L. Henker, B. Whalen, C. K. Axelrod, J. Comer, L. K.
Motherhood in the context of HIV infection: Reading between the numbers
Cultural Diversity and Ethnic Minority Psychology
5 197–208 1999.
10.1037/1099-9809.5.3.197 Google Scholar
- Towsley, G. L. Beck, S. L. Watkins, J. Learning to live with it: Coping with the transition to cancer survivorship in older adults Journal of Ageing Studies 21 93–106 2007.
- Widows, M. R. Jacobsen, B. P. Booth-Jones, M. Fields, K. K. Predictors of posttraumatic growth following bone marrow transplantation for cancer Health Psychology 24 266–273 2005.
- Winterling, J. Wasteson, E. Glimelius, B. Sjoden, P. O. Nordin, K. Substantial changes in life: Perceptions in patients with newly diagnosed advanced cancer and their spouses Cancer Nursing 27 381–388 2004.
- Znoj, H. Bereavement and posttraumatic growth L. G. Calhoun R. Tedeschi Handbook of post-traumatic growth: Research and practice 176–196 Mahwah, NJ Erlbaum 2006.