Meta‐CART: A tool to identify interactions between moderators in meta‐analysis
Abstract
In the framework of meta‐analysis, moderator analysis is usually performed only univariately. When several study characteristics are available that may account for treatment effect, standard meta‐regression has difficulties in identifying interactions between them. To overcome this problem, meta‐CART has been proposed: an approach that applies classification and regression trees (CART) to identify interactions, and then subgroup meta‐analysis to test the significance of moderator effects. The previous version of meta‐CART has its shortcomings: when applying CART, the sample sizes of studies are not taken into account, and the effect sizes are dichotomized around the median value. Therefore, this article proposes new meta‐CART extensions, weighting study effect sizes by their accuracy, and using a regression tree to avoid dichotomization. In addition, new pruning rules are proposed. The performance of all versions of meta‐CART was evaluated via a Monte Carlo simulation study. The simulation results revealed that meta‐regression trees with random‐effects weights and a 0.5‐standard‐error pruning rule perform best. The required sample size for meta‐CART to achieve satisfactory performance depends on the number of study characteristics, the magnitude of the interactions, and the residual heterogeneity.
Citing Literature
Number of times cited according to CrossRef: 11
- C. M. Hoeboer, R. A. De Kleine, M. L. Molendijk, M. Schoorl, D. A. C. Oprel, J. Mouthaan, W. Van der Does, A. Van Minnen, Impact of dissociation on the effectiveness of psychotherapy for post-traumatic stress disorder: meta-analysis, BJPsych Open, 10.1192/bjo.2020.30, 6, 3, (2020).
- Xinru Li, Elise Dusseldorp, Xiaogang Su, Jacqueline J. Meulman, Multiple moderator meta-analysis using the R-package Meta-CART, Behavior Research Methods, 10.3758/s13428-020-01360-0, (2020).
- Xinru Li, Elise Dusseldorp, Jacqueline J. Meulman, A flexible approach to identify interaction effects between moderators in meta‐analysis, Research Synthesis Methods, 10.1002/jrsm.1334, 10, 1, (134-152), (2019).
- Elizabeth Tipton, James E. Pustejovsky, Hedyeh Ahmadi, A history of meta‐regression: Technical, conceptual, and practical developments between 1974 and 2018, Research Synthesis Methods, 10.1002/jrsm.1338, 10, 2, (161-179), (2019).
- Xiaobo Xu, Wenling Liu, Weiguo Pang, Are Emotionally Intelligent People More Creative? A Meta-Analysis of the Emotional Intelligence–Creativity Link, Sustainability, 10.3390/su11216123, 11, 21, (6123), (2019).
- Katie Newby, Grace Teah, Richard Cooke, Xinru Li, Katherine Brown, Bradley Salisbury-Finch, Kayleigh Kwah, Naomi Bartle, Kristina Curtis, Emmie Fulton, Joanne Parsons, Elise Dusseldorp, Stefanie L Williams, Do automated digital health behaviour change interventions have a positive effect on self-efficacy? A systematic review and meta-analysis, Health Psychology Review, 10.1080/17437199.2019.1705873, (1-107), (2019).
- Eleanor R. Bull, Nicola McCleary, Xinru Li, Stephan U. Dombrowski, Elise Dusseldorp, Marie Johnston, Interventions to Promote Healthy Eating, Physical Activity and Smoking in Low-Income Groups: a Systematic Review with Meta-Analysis of Behavior Change Techniques and Delivery/Context, International Journal of Behavioral Medicine, 10.1007/s12529-018-9734-z, 25, 6, (605-616), (2018).
- Lizzie Caperon, Bianca Sykes-Muskett, Faye Clancy, James Newell, Rebecca King, Andrew Prestwich, How effective are interventions in improving dietary behaviour in low- and middle-income countries? A systematic review and meta-analysis, Health Psychology Review, 10.1080/17437199.2018.1481763, 12, 3, (312-331), (2018).
- Emily E. Tanner-Smith, Sean Grant, Meta-Analysis of Complex Interventions, Annual Review of Public Health, 10.1146/annurev-publhealth-040617-014112, 39, 1, (135-151), (2018).
- Nicola McCleary, Amanda Andrews, Audrey Buelo, Mireille Captieux, Susan Morrow, Sharon Wiener-Ogilvie, Monica Fletcher, Liz Steed, Stephanie J. C. Taylor, Hilary Pinnock, IMP2ART systematic review of education for healthcare professionals implementing supported self-management for asthma, npj Primary Care Respiratory Medicine, 10.1038/s41533-018-0108-4, 28, 1, (2018).
- Lisa V Eckerstorfer, Norbert K Tanzer, Claudia Vogrincic-Haselbacher, Gayannee Kedia, Hilmar Brohmer, Isabelle Dinslaken, Katja Corcoran, Key Elements of mHealth Interventions to Successfully Increase Physical Activity: Meta-Regression, JMIR mHealth and uHealth, 10.2196/10076, 6, 11, (e10076), (2018).
